Matt Carpenter Matty Mustache New York Yankees Baseball T-Shirt

Yankees fan favorite's return could be key to Juan Soto trade

Matt Carpenter on mustache fame, Yankees chance, special salsa

New York Yankees Matt Carpenter Matty Mustache Shirt, hoodie, sweater, long sleeve and tank top

Matt Carpenter, Major League Baseball, News, Scores, Highlights, Stats, and Rumors

Matt Carpenter joins list of great Yankees mustaches

Matt Carpenter Matty Mustache New York Yankees baseball shirt, hoodie, sweater, long sleeve and tank top

Matt Carpenter signs major league deal with New York Yankees - ESPN

Matt Carpenter Matty Mustache New York Yankees baseball shirt, hoodie, sweater, long sleeve and tank top

Could Yankees' Matt Carpenter lose spot after home run hot streak?

Baseballer - The power of the stache 👀

You look like a creepy uncle!” - Screaming fan takes a dig at star third baseman Matt Carpenter during New York Yankees vs. Boston Red Sox game

Matt Carpenter on mustache fame, Yankees chance, special salsa

Talkin' Yanks on X: Our first look at Matt Carpenter in his Yankees threads! / X

Matt Carpenter has solid Yankees' debut: 'Pretty crazy